Showing posts with label Psystar. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Psystar. Show all posts

Psystar isn't Closing, Attorney Says

Although Mac clone maker Psystar has turned off the lights at its Web site, the firm is not shutting down permanently, the company's lawyer said today.

Contrary to a report last week by the Dow Jones Newswire ( subscription required ), Psystar is not shutting down permanently, said K.A.D. Camara, of the Houston, Texas firm Camara & Sibley LLP.

Camara represents Psystar in a lawsuit the company filed in a Miami federal court last August that accuses Apple of violating several antitrust laws.

The Dow Jones story quoted Eugene Action, a Fresno, Calif. lawyer who represented Psystar in the lawsuit Apple filed with a San Francisco federal court in 2008. "They will not be in business," Action said, adding that Psystar President Rudy Pedraza would be "shutting things down immediately" by firing the company's eight employees.

However, Camara told Computerworld by e-mail today, "Regrettably, Mr. Action was misquoted in an early story that seems to have been picked up elsewhere," he said. "Psystar does not intend to shut down permanently."

Camara did not elaborate on what form Psystar would take in the future, or when it might return to the Web.

Action did not reply on Friday to a request for clarification of the remarks that Camara said had been misquoted.

The Dow Jones story was used as the source for several stories that repeated Action's claims, including posts on AppleInsider , MacNN and TG Daily .

Action said the Psystar shut-down was prompted by the injunction U.S. District Court Judge William Alsup awarded Apple on Tuesday. The injunction barred Psystar from selling computers with Apple's Mac OS X.

Alsup gave Psystar until midnight, Dec. 31, 2009, to comply with the injunction, and warned the company against dragging it feet. "Defendant must immediately begin this process, and take the quickest path to compliance," Alsup said in the order.

The shuttering of its Web site could be part of the path Psystar is taking to comply with the injunction. The clone maker was required to inform Apple of its plans, but it did not have to make those plans public.

Earlier this month, Psystar halted sales of Intel-based clones pre-loaded with Snow Leopard , and agreed to pay Apple approximately $2.7 million if it loses appeals it plans to file with the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit.

At that time, Camara said that although Psystar was dropping its Mac OS X-loaded machines, it would continue to sell PCs with other operating systems, including Windows, and would also sell its $50 Rebel EFI software . Rebel EFI lets owners of generic PCs install and run Apple's Snow Leopard operating system.

By continuing to market Rebel EFI, Psystar was effectively shifting the responsibility of installing Mac OS X to customers. Psystar would sell Rebel EFI to customers, who would have to obtain a copy of Snow Leopard, then use Rebel EFI to install and run the operating system on a Psystar system.

"Customers can buy Rebel EFI, a machine from us or from Dell, and with Rebel EFI, install OS X on whatever computer they please," Camara said on Dec. 2.

Psystar's Web site , however, went dark yesterday. As of 7 p.m. ET Friday, it remained offline.

Psystar has several legal moves left to make, Camara said today. "Psystar will proceed to litigate the legality of Rebel EFI through the motion process described in Judge Alsup's order," Camara said. "Psystar will also proceed with its antitrust case in Miami."

Psystar and Apple have been tangling in court since July 2008, when Apple sued the clone maker over copyright and software licensing violations. Psystar first started selling Intel machines with Mac OS X pre-installed in April 2008 .

Apple wins permanent injunction against Psystar

It is the end of the line for Psystar as U.S. District Judge William Alsup has issued a permanent injunction against the Apple clone maker. The injunction prevents Psystar from pursuing its core hardware business by banning the following:

  • Copying, selling, offering to sell, distributing, or creating derivative works of plaintiff’s copyrighted Mac OS X software without authorization from the copyright holder
  • Intentionally inducing, aiding, assisting, abetting, or encouraging any other person or entity to infringe plaintiff’s copyrighted Mac OS X software;
  • Circumventing any technological measure that effectively controls access to plaintiff’s copyrighted Mac OS X software, including, but not limited to, the technological measure used by Apple to prevent unauthorized copying of Mac OS X on non-Apple computers
  • Manufacturing, importing, offering to the public, providing, or otherwise trafficking in any technology, product, service, device, component, or part thereof that is primarily designed or produced for the purpose of circumventing a technological measure that effectively controls access to plaintiff’s copyrighted Mac OS X software, including, but not limited to, the technological measure used by Apple to prevent unauthorized copying of Mac OS X on non-Apple computer
  • Manufacturing, importing, offering to the public, providing, or otherwise trafficking in any technology, product, service, device, component, or part thereof that is primarily designed or produced for the purpose of circumventing a technological measure that effectively protects the rights held by plaintiff under the Copyright Act with respect to its copyrighted Mac OS X software.

Psystar has until December 31th, 2009 to fully comply with the ruling and must begin the process immediately using a method that provides the fastest route to compliance. Psystar may have to shutter the hardware portion of its business but the legal status of Psystar’s $50 Rebel EFI software remains unclear. In his ruling, Alsup does not cite the Rebel EFI software specifically, claiming that Psystar failed to disclose exactly what the application did. In case Psystar has high hopes of continuing to sell its Rebel EFI software, Alsup issued a stern warning, ‘What is certain, however, is that until such a motion is brought, Psystar will be selling Rebel EFI at its peril, and risks finding itself in contempt if its new venture falls within the scope of the injunction.” Will this admonishment permanently close the doors on Psystar or will the rebel company stage one last battle?

Apple Wins Key Legal Round in Battle With Psystar

Apple Inc. has won an important round in its legal battle against Psystar Corp., which sells computers based on the Apple Macintosh operating system.

Apple first accused Psystar of copyright infringement in a lawsuit filed in July 2008, which was about four months after Psystar began selling its machines.

Recently, both sides asked U.S. District Judge William Alsup to decide on many of the case's key issues, including, as Psystar alleges, whether Apple, based in Cupertino, Calif., is abusing its Macintosh software copyright.

On Friday, Judge Alsup ruled in Apple's favor and against Psystar.

"Psystar's use of Mac OS X has been in excess and has violated Apple's copyrights," the judge wrote at one point in his 16-page order.

The decision appears to gut Psystar's entire line of defense, according to the legal Web site Groklaw. "Psystar is toast," Groklaw wrote.

An Apple representative didn't immediately respond to requests Sunday for comment.

A spokesman for Psystar couldn't immediately be reached for comment.

Psystar filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy protection in May.

On its Web site Sunday, Psystar, based in Doral, Fla., offered three different desktop computers capable of using Apple's operating system, with prices ranging from $599 to $1,499.

powered by Blogger | WordPress by Newwpthemes | Converted by BloggerTheme